IR Coffee Readings Archive

(March 5, 2017)
Finlay_2016.pdf download View | Download
Citation: Finlay, Christopher J. (2016) "Bastards, brothers, and unjust warriors: Enmity and ethics in Just War Cinema." Review of International Studies 43 (1): 73–94. doi:10.1017/S0260210516000255.

Abstract: How do members of the general public come to regard some uses of violence as legitimate and others as illegitimate? And how do they learn to use widely recognised normative principles in doing so such as those encapsulated in the laws of war and debated by just war theorists? This article argues that popular cinema is likely to be a major source of influence especially through a subgenre that I call 'Just War Cinema'. Since the 1950s, many films have addressed the moral drama at the centre of contemporary Just War Theory through the figure of the enemy in the Second World War, offering often explicit and sophisticated treatments of the relationship between the jus ad bellum and the jus in bello that anticipate or echo the arguments of philosophers. But whereas Cold War-era films may have supported Just War Theory's ambitions to shape public understanding, a strongly revisionary tendency in Just War Cinema since the late 1990s is just as likely to thwart them. The potential of Just War Cinema to vitiate efforts to shape wider attitudes is a matter that both moral philosophers and those concerned with disseminating the law of war ought to pay close attention to.
Categories: IR Coffee Archives
(March 5, 2017)
Gibler_Miller_Little_2016.pdf download View | Download
Citation: Gibler, Douglas M., Steven V. Miller, and Erin K. Little. (2016) "An Analysis of the Militarized Interstate Dispute (MID) Dataset, 1816–2001." International Studies Quarterly 60: 719–730. doi: 10.1093/isq/sqw045.

Abstract: This research note discusses a five-year examination of the original coding work of the Militarized Interstate Dispute (MID) project. After strictly applying MID coding rules, we recommend dropping 251 cases (or over 10% of the dataset), as either we were unable to find a militarized incident in the historical record or the dispute appeared elsewhere in the data. We found evidence linking 75 disputes to other cases, and we could not identify 19 cases in the historical record. Among the remaining disputes, we recommend major changes (changes in dispute year, fatality level, and participants) in 234 disputes and minor changes in 1,009 disputes. We use this article to examine the potential impact of our suggestions on existing studies. Though we identified several systematic problems with the original coding effort, we also find that these problems do not affect current understandings of what predicts the onset of interstate conflict. However, estimates in our replications of three recent studies of dispute escalation, dispute duration, and dispute reciprocation all witness substantial changes when using corrected data—to the point of reversing previous conclusions in some cases.

Revised datasets:
Categories: IR Coffee Archives
(February 7, 2017)
Science-Prediction.pdf download View | Download
Citation: Jasny, Barbara R., et al. (2017) "Special Section: Prediction and Its Limits." Science 355(6324): 469-489. Abstract: A special section on prediction in the social sciences, with essays by John Bohannon on online data and polling; Lars-Erik Cederman and Nils B. Weidmann on the prediction of conflict; Philip E. Tetlock, Barbara A. Mellers, and J. Peter Scoblic on forecasting tournaments; and more.
Categories: IR Coffee Archives
(February 4, 2017)
Abramson_Carter_2016.pdf download View | Download
Citation: Abramson, Scott F., and David B. Carter. (2016) "The Historical Origins of Territorial Disputes." APSR 110(4):675-698, doi:10.1017/S0003055416000381.

Abstract: Given the abundance of evidence that disputed territory matters, we know remarkably little about the origins of territorial claims. We argue that the presence of competing historical border precedents is central to the emergence of territorial claims. We outline why precedents provide opportunity to make claims and provide two possible explanations for why leaders have incentive to claim along precedents. One possibility is consistent with the conventional wisdom that incentive derives from territorial characteristics such as natural resources or strategic significance. A second and more novel explanation is that the persistent coordination effects of historical boundaries provide the incentive to draw claims along them. We use new data on the location of historical boundaries from the peace of Westphalia until the start of the French Revolution to show that historical border precedents drive the emergence of territorial claims after the Congress of Vienna and that persistent coordination effects provide incentive to dispute historical precedents.
Categories: IR Coffee Archives
(February 3, 2017)
Samii-2016.pdf download View | Download
Citation: Samii, Cyrus. (2016) "Causal Empiricism in Quantitative Research." JOP 78(3):941-955.

Abstract: Quantitative analysis of causal effects in political science has trended toward the adoption of "causal empiricist" approaches. Such approaches place heavy emphasis on causal identification through experimental and natural experimental designs and on characterizing the specific subpopulations for which effects are identified. This trend is eroding the position of traditional regression studies as the prevailing convention for quantitative causal research in political science. This essay clarifies what is at stake. I provide a causal empiricist critique of conventional regression studies, a statement of core pillars of causal empiricism, and a discussion of how causal empiricism and theory interact. I propose that the trend toward causal empiricism should be welcomed by a broad array of political scientists. The trend fits into a broader push to reimagine our discipline in terms of collective research programs with high standards for evidence and a research division of labor.

Categories: IR Coffee Archives
(January 23, 2017)
Agents-without-Agency.pdf download View | Download
Citation: Côté, Adam. (2016) "Agents without agency: Assessing the role of the audience in securitization theory." Security Dialogue 47(6):541-558.

Abstract: This article assesses the role of the audience in securitization theory. The main argument is that in order to accurately capture the role of the securitization audience, it must be theorized as an active agent, capable of having a meaningful effect on the intersubjective construction of security values. Through a meta-synthesis of 32 empirical studies of securitization, this article focuses on two central questions: (1) Who is the audience? (2) How does the audience engage in the construction of security? When assessed against the theoretical works on securitization, this analysis reveals that the manner in which the audience is defined and characterized within securitization theory differs with the empirical literature that investigates securitization processes. Where the empirical literature suggests securitization is a highly intersubjective process involving active audiences, securitization theory characterizes audiences as agents without agency, thereby marginalizing the theory's intersubjective nature. This article sketches a new characterization of the securitization audience and outlines a framework for securitizing actor–audience interaction that better accounts for securitization theory's linguistic and intersubjective character, addresses this theoretical/empirical conflict, and improves our understanding of how groups select and justify security priorities and costly security policies.

Categories: IR Coffee Archives
(January 16, 2017)
Mao_2017.pdf download View | Download
Citation: Mao, Andrew, Lili Dworkin, Siddharth Suri, and Duncan J. Watts. (2017) "Resilient cooperators stabilize long-run cooperation in the finitely repeated Prisoner's Dilemma." Nature Communications 8, article 13800, doi: 10.1038/ncomms13800.

Abstract: Learning in finitely repeated games of cooperation remains poorly understood in part because their dynamics play out over a timescale exceeding that of traditional lab experiments. Here, we report results of a virtual lab experiment in which 94 subjects play up to 400 ten-round games of Prisoner's Dilemma over the course of twenty consecutive weekdays. Consistent with previous work, the typical round of first defection moves earlier for several days; however, this unravelling process stabilizes after roughly one week. Analysing individual strategies, we find that approximately 40% of players behave as resilient cooperators who avoid unravelling even at significant cost to themselves. Finally, using a standard learning model we predict that a sufficiently large minority of resilient cooperators can permanently stabilize unravelling among a majority of rational players. These results shed hopeful light on the long-term dynamics of cooperation, and demonstrate the importance of long-run experiments.

Categories: IR Coffee Archives
(January 12, 2017)
Watts-2017.pdf download View | Download
Citation: Watts, Duncan. (2017) "Should social science be more solution-oriented?" Nature Human Behaviour 1, article 0015, doi:10.1038/s41562-016-0015.

Abstract: Over the past 100 years, social science has generated a tremendous number of theories on the topics of individual and collective human behaviour. However, it has been much less successful at reconciling the innumerable inconsistencies and contradictions among these competing explanations, a situation that has not been resolved by recent advances in 'computational social science.' In this Perspective, I argue that this 'incoherency problem' has been perpetuated by an historical emphasis in social science on the advancement of theories over the solution of practical problems. I argue that one way for social science to make progress is to adopt a more solution-oriented approach, starting first with a practical problem and then asking what theories (and methods) must be brought to bear to solve it. Finally, I conclude with a few suggestions regarding the sort of problems on which progress might be made and how we might organize ourselves to solve them.

Categories: IR Coffee Archives
(January 10, 2017)
Fukuyama_2016.pdf download View | Download
Citation: Fukuyama, Francis. (2016) "Governance: What Do We Know, and How Do We Know It?" Annual Review of Political Science 19: 89-105.

Abstract: The term governance does not have a settled definition today, and it has at least three main meanings. The first is international cooperation through nonsovereign bodies outside the state system. This concept grew out of the literature on globalization and argued that territorial sovereignty was giving way to more informal types of horizontal cooperation, as well as to supranational bodies such as the European Union. The second meaning treated governance as a synonym for public administration, that is, effective implementation of state policy. Interest in this topic was driven by awareness that global poverty was rooted in corruption and weak state capacity. The third meaning of governance was the regulation of social behavior through networks and other nonhierarchical mechanisms. The first and third of these strands of thought downplay traditional state authority and favor new transnational or civil society actors. These trends, however, raise troubling questions about transparency and accountability in the workings of modern government.

Categories: IR Coffee Archives
(December 3, 2016)
Larson_Lewis_AJPS.pdf download View | Download
Citation: Larson, Jennifer M., and Janet I. Lewis. "Ethnic Networks." Forthcoming, American Journal of Political Science.

Abstract: Active research on a wide range of political contexts centers on ethnicity's role in collective action. Many theories posit that information flows more easily in ethnically homogeneous areas, facilitating collective action, because social networks among coethnics are denser. Although this characterization is ubiquitous, little empirical work assesses it. Through a novel field experiment in a matched pair of villages in rural Uganda, this article directly examines word-of-mouth information spread and its relationship to ethnic diversity and networks. As expected, information spread more widely in the homogeneous village. However, unexpectedly, the more diverse village's network is significantly denser. Using unusually detailed network data, we offer an explanation for why network density may hamper information dissemination in heterogeneous areas, showing why even slight hesitation to share information with people from other groups can have large aggregate effects.
Categories: IR Coffee Archives